Talking with Prof. Dr. Ulrich H. J. Körtner and Prof. Dr. Gerhard Kruip
Migration is one of the most controversial political and social issues of our time. Between humanitarian responsibility, the state’s capacity to act and the limits of what is doable – tensions arise that cannot be easily resolved. Prof. Dr Ulrich H. J. Körtner and Prof. Dr Gerhard Kruip discuss these issues in their new book ‘Ist Migration zu begrenzen?’ (Should Migration Be Restricted?) from different ethical perspectives and demonstrate how a nuanced and respectful dialogue can be achieved. As part of the Nomos NOESIS newsletter, we speak to them about the various perspectives in the migration debate.
Dear Professor Körtner, dear Professor Kruip, the issue of migration has been one of the most contentious topics in our society for years. Do you see any progress in the debate, or is the discussion becoming increasingly polarised?
Körtner: The number of asylum applications is falling sharply in Germany and Austria, as it is across the EU as a whole. The convergence of moderate parties on asylum policy is also helping to tone down the political debate. In opinion polls, the issue of asylum and migration is not currently at the top of the list of priorities. This offers an opportunity to make the debate more objective. I fear, however, that should the numbers rise again, the discussion would become more polemical, which would primarily benefit right-wing populist parties. Yet it does not help to make the migration debate more objective if obvious problems – such as the negative consequences of poverty-driven migration from South-Eastern Europe in some major German cities – are downplayed, even if the motives behind doing so are entirely honourable.
Kruip: Back in 2015, I was deeply shaken by the polemical reactions to Angela Merkel’s policies and her statement ‘We can do it!’, which was characterised by great optimism and trust in the goodwill of the people of Germany. Unfortunately, such opposition also came from the centre-right parties, whilst the churches actually gave Merkel a great deal of support. There is much to suggest that it was this opposition that really gave the AfD its initial momentum. She would probably have gained less political capital from the high number of immigrants had Merkel been more clearly supported from within her own ranks. Because the situation in Syria has since changed and the current federal government is pursuing a policy of restricting migration – which, incidentally, partly contravenes European law – the debate appears to have become somewhat calmer, though not necessarily more objective. And it could flare up again at any time.
You have co-authored a book entitled “Should Migration Be Restricted?”. It actually raises two questions …
Körtner: One question is: Is it actually possible to effectively restrict migration, and if so, by means that are in accordance with the rule of law and human rights? The other question is: Is restricting migration morally permissible?
Is it even possible to limit the influx of people from non-European countries into Germany or Austria?
Körtner: This is certainly possible, both politically and legally. However, unilateral action by individual countries is not enough; what is needed is a pan-European strategy, including cooperation with countries of origin.
Kruip: People suffering from extreme hardship or severe repression will always try to come to Europe, and it will be very difficult to prevent them from doing so without acting in an inhumane manner. In Africa, the poorest continent, the population is set to double over the next 30 years. Much greater efforts must be made to tackle the root causes of flight, whilst at the same time seeking to regulate migration in such a way as to avoid inhuman hardship as far as possible.
And the second question: Should one, may one, or must one limit this influx – or is this precisely what must not happen? How do you assess this from the perspective of theological ethics?
Körtner: Christian ethics, which are guided by the double commandment to love God and one’s neighbour, have a universal principle of helping one’s neighbour; however, this does not mean providing unlimited help to everyone at the same time. Anyone who argues one-sidedly on the basis of the commandment to love one’s neighbour or Jesus’ parable of the Last Judgement in Matthew 25 quickly confuses the level of individual ethics with that of social ethics. The complex biblical teachings on flight and migration are often presented in a highly simplified manner. Responsible politics and the ethics of responsibility require us to gain clarity on the meaning, necessity and, at times, the tragedy of borders. Help for the vulnerable and those in need of protection, in particular, depends on a functioning constitutional and welfare state, which cannot survive without borders. Irregular migration, as we have been experiencing it for more than ten years, also leads to great injustice, because it favours the strong and those with sufficient money to pay people-smugglers. Another aspect of the tragedy in a less-than-ideal world is that individual and collective resources are limited. A painful conflict can arise between what we wish to do and what we are capable of doing. A country’s capacity to receive migrants does not depend solely on monetary and economic factors, but also on cultural factors, if the integration of immigrants is to succeed.
Kruip: According to Catholic social teaching, all people belong to the human family and the earth’s resources are there for everyone. Against this backdrop, the current extreme inequality in life chances around the world is a scandal. The random lottery of birth determines whether one grows up in prosperity and with legal security and can travel the world (as we Germans do, for example), or whether one suffers from war and extreme poverty and can only reach other places by mostly illegal means (as is the case, for example, with the people living in the Gaza Strip). An ideal world would be one in which no one were forced to leave their country due to hardship or persecution, whilst at the same time global freedom of movement were permitted. We are, of course, a long way from that. On the path towards this goal, it is legitimate to set priorities and to take in those who are in particular need. There are certainly limits to our capacity to take people in; however, these must not be dictated by the loud voices of far-right forces. It is morally reprehensible when precisely those countries that contribute little to the global fight against poverty – or even exacerbate it – simultaneously close their borders to migrants.